Sunset Steak & Cheese: A 1956 Diner Reborn as a Cheesesteak Joint
There’s been a sign reading “Sunset Restaurant” over 180 St. Paul Street since 1956. The letters have faded in the sun, and the people of St. Catharines have walked past them for almost seventy years. When chef Zach Smith and his partners took over the building, the first decision was the simplest one: the sign stays. Sunset Steak & Cheese opens on November 20 behind the same storefront, with roughly 90 seats, a new kitchen and a lot of respect for what came before.
A storefront that waited ten years
For decades the building was a Greek breakfast diner, run by the same family since it opened. Before 1956 it was an Italian steakhouse, and menus from both eras are still stored in the basement. Smith first noticed the place about ten years ago, when he was visiting St. Catharines and wondering whether to leave the big city for a smaller market. He went in and asked the owners whether they’d sell. They said no.
When the diner finally went on the market this year, he didn’t feel he could let it go, even though, as he puts it, it was “against my better judgment.” He has already opened several restaurants and has a three-month-old baby at home. “It would have been such a shame to just let it turn into a store,” he says. “There’s still menus in the basement from 1956. To have somebody just come in and wipe that away would have been heartbreaking.” Designer Keri Maclellan kept as much of the original character as she could. The goal was to lift the room, not erase it. The biggest change is the hours: the breakfast counter is now a place to eat at night.
From Toronto kitchens to the Niagara region
Smith comes from Vancouver and spent about thirteen years in Toronto restaurants, including four as chef at Barraval. When the pandemic hit, he and his wife both lost their jobs while caring for a six-month-old baby. They moved to Niagara, where she grew up. In 2023 he opened Fat Rabbit, a butcher shop, restaurant and catering business. In its first year it made the Michelin Guide’s first selection outside Toronto and ranked eighth on Air Canada’s list of best new restaurants. People now drive in from the GTA, and some come from as far as Nashville. Les Incompétents came next, a “French-ish” seafood bar named after a line from Home Alone. In November 2026, Les Incompétents landed the #9 spot on the Air Canada’s Best New Restaurants list. This year Smith also went back to Bar Raval as executive chef and partner, and helped open Casa Rubia next door.
Philadelphia, as seen from Ontario
The storefront reminded Smith of Schwartz’s in Montreal, so a smoked meat deli was an early idea. The team settled on cheesesteaks for two reasons: nobody in town was making them, and the Greek diner had served its own versions for years. “We’ve never been to Philadelphia,” Smith admits, with the same cheerful honesty that led a team with no French speakers to open a French bar. Instead of copying the classics, Sunset Steak & Cheese nods to them and then has some fun.
There are two traditional cheesesteaks at $26, each with half a pound of beef on a semolina roll. A local bakery makes the roll to Sunset’s recipe, and Smith says finding the right bread was the hardest part of the project. One version uses Cheez Whiz. The other uses a house blend of Canadian cheeses designed to taste like Cooper Sharp, a cheese you can’t get in Canada. “If you eat that whole thing, you’re done,” he laughs. “Or you can share it with a friend and order some sides.”
His own favourite sandwich is the shawarma chicken and cheese.The chicken thigh is treated like rib steak: sliced thin, chopped on the flat-top with cheese, then finished with garlic sauce, pickled turnips and sumac onions.
The Szechuan chicken finger sandwich on Texas toast, at $16, is a nod to the building’s diner past. A chili cheese dog is $10, and starters and sides cost $9 to $13. “The goal is to keep that final bill reasonable,” he says. To drink, there’s Coca-Cola on tap, ice-cold cheap beer and a cocktail list from bartender Anna Wolkowski.
A place for the whole neighbourhood
Sunset Steak & Cheese sits right beside the Meridian Centre, where the Niagara IceDogs play. The arena also hosts concerts and pro basketball, and downtown fills up on game nights. Smith wants Sunset to be the obvious stop before and after an event. With Brock University nearby, he also wants students to be able to afford it. On Sundays the restaurant opens at noon, and the back room’s TVs will show football. Delivery isn’t the focus yet, but daytime takeout, from noon to 5 p.m., is planned for a second phase once the bakery can keep up. Smith’s partners are Bernard Lim, Adam Gentino and Emily Walker. “I want it to be for everybody,” he says, from students to hockey fans to “a place where you can take your grandkids.”
The faded sign on St. Paul Street now has a new job. Sunset is no longer serving eggs and coffee, but the lights will be on well past dark.
Written by Valérie Boutet
Photography by Scott Usheroff