Martine and Jonathan Bauer: The Perfect Pairing
They had given themselves until June. A year earlier, Martine and Jonathan Bauer had left everything behind in Paris: their jobs, their routines, careers built in some of France’s grandest houses. They had crossed the Atlantic with their children, a childhood friend and his family, and signed a lease in Toronto. Then they waited for keys that never came. The deal they made with each other was simple: if nothing turned up before the summer of 2019, they would go back to France in time for the new school year. The keys came in June, right before their deadline. They built the restaurant with their own hands, because their contractor had walked away. Everything was ready to open in April 2020. Yes, you read that right. “We didn’t open during COVID. We opened during lockdown. That’s not quite the same thing.”
She’s a chef, he’s a sommelier. Together for nearly twenty years, they complete each other’s sentences, correct each other’s dates when telling stories and tease each other the way only people who have been through everything side by side can. Today, with their partner Maxime, they run Bar Pompette, Bar Allegro and Bakery Pompette, three neighbouring addresses on College Street. Their whole story comes down to one reflex: when the ground gives way, sit down together and decide fast.
Born for Hospitality
They both say it plainly: they were average students. Neither of them ever considered doing anything else than hospitality. “It’s a calling.”
In 2005, in Mauritius, a young cook steps off a plane with no idea what’s waiting for her. In the airport hall there are buses full of students from her hotel school, her parents, whom someone drove over from the house just for the occasion, the radio, the television. Martine is back from France with the Grand Cordon d’or de la cuisine française, won against the top students from a dozen schools, from Paris to Monaco. It was her very first competition. The island had never won it before. It hasn’t won it since. “I absolutely wasn’t expecting that.”
Nobody in that hall could see the year that came before. Up at 6 a.m., the bus, school until 4 p.m., then the hotel until midnight. The next day, the same again. When school was out, she was at work; when work was out, she was at school. “She had zero days off,” Jonathan says, still impressed twenty years later.
He grew up in Strasbourg. He went to hotel school at 15 to become a cook, an unapologetic food lover, and spent a long time torn between pastry and wine. What tipped the scales was people. In the kitchen, “you’re in an intense rhythm and you never see the guests.” Wine opened every door: the winemakers, “extremely passionate and fascinating,” the guests, the chefs, and also history, geology, geography. A stint with Michel Bras in Laguiole taught him the “very human approach to things” that has stayed with him ever since.
One day, a teacher told him about an assistant head sommelier job at a palace hotel in Mauritius. Two hours on the phone, and the next day, the visa application was in. For one year, he thought.
He stayed four. “Except we met,” Martine says with a smile.
All or Nothing
The island is small, with no vineyards, and the horizons there run out quickly. In 2009, Jonathan’s head sommelier quietly signed him up for the Best Young Sommelier of France competition. If he qualified, the hotel would pay for the second plane ticket. He qualified. He won. “Nobody in France knew who I was.”
In 2010, Martine and Jonathan made the leap to Paris. For Martine, the vertigo was real: “From Mauritius to Paris, it’s all or nothing.” She refused to leave without a job and landed one at the Royal Monceau before her plane even touched down. A month later, Jonathan called her: he’d found work, guess where. The Royal Monceau.
Their Paris years shaped each of them in their own way. Martine moved to the kitchens of the French Prime Minister, where she would serve under three different prime ministers. Hired to feed the 400 people who worked there, she was spotted within a month by the head chef, a former Michelin-starred cook, who realized she knew how to make “real cooking.” She was put in charge of meals for the Prime Minister, his wife and their children. The same table every day, and the unspoken rule never to serve the same dish twice, “unless they ask you to.”
Jonathan, meanwhile, was collecting titles: a team competition won in 2012 with the Royal Monceau, then the crown of Best Sommelier of France in 2014. He became head sommelier for Daniel Rose, an American chef who cooked Escoffier with fresh eyes. Guests would rave about a dish that felt “so modern,” and the chef would come out with the book open, dated 1912. Seventeen employees, fourteen nationalities: the taste for a wider world was there to stay.
Leaving for Real
Then came the moment when everything tightened. They were employees, respected, but tired of having to go through “10,000 people” to change the smallest detail. They wanted to do their thing. There were the 2015 attacks, which they lived through while Martine was pregnant, and a sense of insecurity that never quite lifted. And competition that had gone wild: “Being good wasn’t enough for it to work.” Opening a restaurant in Paris had become a lottery.
Why Toronto rather than Montreal? There were a few reasons. First, Martine and Jonathan were drawn to Toronto’s cosmopolitan character, its cultural diversity, and the idea of raising their children in a truly international city. Second, after leaving Paris, they were looking for a real change of scene. Moving to another French-speaking city might have felt too familiar, and they were ready for something different. Finally, Canada offered the quality of life they were looking for: a place where they could continue working hard and pursuing their ambitions, while making more time for family and watching their children grow up. Learning English was a welcome bonus rather than a driving force behind their decision.
Martine and Jonathan didn’t leave alone. Maxime, who has been Jonathan’s friend since they were 15. Best Young Bartender of France, a wife from another country, children born two days apart from the couple’s own: the parallels are almost dizzying. The two friends even quit their Paris jobs the same week without talking it over. “He’s my twin brother,” Jonathan says, before correcting himself: “No, but it’s pretty uncanny.”
Martine, for her part, dreaded the cold. On their scouting trip, in February, the weather was mild and there was barely any snow. She signed. The winter they moved, it was minus 24 with 30 centimetres of snow on the ground. She still laughs about it: they lied to her!
Seven Concepts in One Year
The lease they signed in 2018 hid a trap. The landlord owned the whole block, the zoning was about to change, and he dreamed of building a condo. Rather than say so, he kept pushing back the handover of the keys, again and again, hoping they would give up. It took lawyers, an out-of-court settlement, and a fresh start from zero, with the clock ticking toward June.
Once the doors opened, lockdown called the shots. A brand-new restaurant meant no government help. Salaries to pay, a team, rent, and a landlord who expected his money every month. So every time Doug Ford stepped up to the microphone, the trio sat down. Within 45 minutes, a new concept was born. In the first year there were seven: fine dining to go, tarte flambée and gnocchi, après-ski when the patio dropped to minus 5.
Designed as a wine and cocktail bar, Pompette became a restaurant almost in spite of itself, discovered through its food. Eight months after opening, enRoute magazine named it the best fine dining restaurant. “We laughed. We didn’t know we were doing fine dining.” They went with it. From those months of survival they kept a muscle: “Today, change doesn’t scare us.”
The Bread, the Bar, the Home
Bar Pompette opened next door in 2021, followed by the bakery in 2023. Three Pompettes on the same street turned out to be one too many: guests would book at one address and show up at the other. In February, the original bar became Bar Allegro, returning to the initial idea: good cocktails at fair prices, paired with simple yet thoughtful dishes designed for sharing, all in a relaxed and welcoming atmosphere.
The bakery is Martine’s domain. At the restaurant, bread was always made in-house because, for them, “you can’t eat your dish without bread.” After dinner, guests would ask to take a loaf home for the next morning’s breakfast. When the pastry shop next door closed, the answer was obvious. And Jonathan, the one-time pastry lover? “He has the patience to eat it,” Martine shoots back.
But it’s Allegro that’s closest to their hearts. It was the first, the one they built themselves, and the only one where they notice everything and critique everything. “It’s our home.” At the restaurant, on the other hand, they can walk in “almost with a guest’s eye.” Their one rule has never changed: create places where they would want to go themselves.
The Throuple
“We make a really beautiful throuple,” Martine says. While the couple makes an iconic duo, they are actually a trio with Max. There are disagreements, obviously, but no decision is ever made alone. In the end, the rule is the same for all three: accept it when the other person is right, because everyone wants the same thing. Eight years on, the trio is still standing. “I’m proud of that.”
Side by Side
There’s no plan to scatter Pompettes across the map. It all works because the three doors are touching and they can drop by every day. In the evening, one of them is on College Street, the other at home with the kids.
A business that runs without them? They think about it, like every restaurateur does. But they still need to work services, to see their teams, to be there, “even if we just come in for a drink, just to stop by and say hello.” “It’s in our DNA.” Martine asks the question out loud: “If I stop doing this job, then what?” It holds for both of them: neither has ever done anything else, and they don’t want to. They were born for this.
In 2019, Martine and Jonathan gave themselves until June to find one door in Toronto. Today they have three, side by side on College Street.
Written by Valérie Boutet
Photography by Scott Usheroff