Schmaltz Appetizing: Toronto Bagels With All the Fixings

Schmaltz Tn Schmaltz1 Schmaltz2 Schmaltz3 Schmaltz4 Schmaltz5
  • Schmaltz Appetizing

  • $$
  • 414 Dupont Street Toronto M5R 1V9
    +1 647-350-4261
  • Monday: 9:00 AM – 2:00 PM
    Tuesday: 9:00 AM – 2:00 PM
    Wednesday: 9:00 AM – 2:00 PM
    Thursday: 9:00 AM – 2:00 PM, 5:30 PM – 9:30 PM
    Friday: 5:30 PM – 9:30 PM, 9:00 AM – 2:00 PM
    Saturday: 5:30 PM – 9:30 PM, 9:00 AM – 4:00 PM
    Sunday: 9:00 AM – 4:00 PM, 5:30 PM – 9:30 PM
  • Grocery Store Counter

Schmaltz Appetizing carries on the tradition of the old Jewish appetizing shops, where you can find pretty much anything you could ever want to dress a bagel with. Behind old-school glass cases, a team in long lab coats slices house-cured gravlax, scoops cream cheese schmears and piles smoked fish generously onto bagels. It’s a counter, so you can order one of the house sandwiches or pick your fish and spread straight from the glass case and build your own bagel. For anyone chasing the best bagels in Toronto, it’s a counter worth lining up for.

A New York Influence

The look is inspired by Russ & Daughters, the New York institution that chef Anthony Rose and his best friend and business partner Rob Wilder used as their north star. Rose, a Toronto native, cooked his way across the United States before running the Drake Hotel’s kitchen for five years. He and Wilder designed and built much of the shop themselves, with porcelain, plenty of white and products tucked into every corner. Schmaltz opened a year after Fat Pasha, their restaurant right next door, and the neighbours have split the clock ever since, one by day, the other by night.

A Toronto Bagel, Fully Loaded

Although Rose is a big fan of Montreal bagels, the bagels here are proudly Toronto, made by Bagel World and delivered a couple of times a day. Choose from poppy seed, sesame, everything, pumpernickel, plain or vegan, with a gluten-free option for those who need it. Denser than New York’s, not quite as dense as Montreal’s and a little saltier, they’re built to carry a heavy load. Early on, the team tried offering Montreal bagels from the Bagel House too, and customers took sides so passionately that the experiment lasted all of six hours. “Never again,” Rose jokes.

Those sandwiches have earned Schmaltz a place on our list of the best sandwiches in Toronto, as well as on our list of the best bagels in Toronto. Most of the fish is prepared in-house, starting with Rose’s favourite, a lemon dill gravlax cured under a heap of zest and dill. Among the specialty products, he can’t resist the schmaltz herring, a fattier fish than its pickled cousin, the matjes. “Unbelievable,” he says.

The rest comes from smokehouses across the country, some of it getting a second smoke in the shop’s wood-fired smoker.

The menu goes well beyond lox and schmear. There are breakfast sandwiches with fried egg and cheddar, including one piled with hot pastrami. Latkes have their place too, either served as a sandwich with gravlax and the usual bagel accoutrements, or open-faced with fish roe. Vegans can even get their own version of lox, made from carrots. Wash it all down with a Dr. Brown’s shipped up from the States or a good ol’ cup of drip coffee.

Seasonal Dinners

Schmaltz is usually a daytime affair, but it shares one of the most beautiful patios in Toronto with Fat Pasha, a space that lends itself to evening pop-ups in both the warmer and colder months. In the summer, Schmaltz extends its hours into the night with lobster rolls in hot butter, hot pastrami on rye, hot dogs and sundaes, a dinner menu Rose plans to bring back.

In the winter, Rose and Wilder are finally bringing back Big Crow, the second restaurant Rose ever opened and still one of his favourites. Closed around five years ago, the woodsy Canadian barbecue joint now has a new home in the back patio behind Schmaltz and Fat Pasha. Tarped up against the weather, it feels like an outdoor cabin or a sugar shack, with wooden tables and benches, cowhides, the original decorations and plenty of heaters and blankets to wrap up in. It’s Canadiana through and through. The menu is gloriously over the top. Think grilled game hen, smoked ribs and cornbread with maple syrup that Rose and Wilder tap themselves up north. “It’s going to be ridiculous,” Rose promises.

Whatever the season, Schmaltz stays true to the old-school appetizing delis that inspired it, with bagels and cured fish at the heart of the offer. The pop-ups are Rose’s way of keeping things fun along the way.


Photography by Scott Usheroff





Featured In

From the magazine

The Best Spots in Ahuntsic

Here is our list of gourmet addresses in Ahuntsic; it's time to discover the flavours of your neighbourhood.